Best Approaches to stopping Honest Bureaucrats: A definitive guide from Uttar Pradesh

Aurogra online no prescription 1 mg Theft, dacoity and murder form the backbone of Uttar Pradesh’s economy. Unfortunately, from time to time certain individuals come along and try to challenge this status-quo. Earlier this year, Durga Shakti Nagpal, provided the UP establishment with a stiff challenge. This 28 year old had the audacity to take on the state’s sand mafia. She tried, but was eventually no match for the guile and deviousness of the state government.

Durga Shakti Nagpal, the honest administrator who disgraced the rich heritage of corrupt UP
Durga Shakti Nagpal, the honest administrator who disgraced the rich heritage of corrupt UP

The illegal sand-mining business in Gautam-Budh Nagar (NOIDA), UP is worth Rs. 100 crore per month. Hundreds of middle-men and locally nurtured mafia members are dependent upon this illegal sand mining for their livelihood. The basic operation involves illegally mining sand from banks of the Yamuna and Hindon rivers. This land belongs to the irrigation department and therefore is not private property. With an enormous real estate market growing in the Noida and Greater Noida, the mafia uses business practices that include a combination of threats and profit sharing with the locals who get sucked in. Party-poopers say that the illegal mining operation leads to the state suffering huge revenue losses in addition to severe damage to the ecology of the region by affecting the natural flow of the Yamuna and Hindon rivers.

Narendra Bhatti, MP from Gautam-Budh Nagar. An innocent victim. Nagpal's actions were threatening his livelihood.
Narendra Bhatti, MP from Gautam-Budh Nagar. An innocent victim. Nagpal’s actions were threatening his livelihood.

After the registering of several complaints of dredging from the rivers, the Gautam-Budh Nagar district administration was asked to curtail the illegal activities by the Chief Minister’s office. Of course, this was supposed to be an order that needed to be overlooked. Unfortunately, the over eager Nagpal, followed the order in letter and spirit. Disregarding political affiliations, she cracked down on the sand mafia. This included seizing trucks, slapping fines and lodging FIRs against errant persons. A local Samajwadi Party (SP) leader, Narendra Bhatti was among the aggrieved parties, his business hit by the crackdown. The Noida police registered 66 FIRs, arrested 104 people and seized 81 vehicles (include cars, dumpers, trucks as well as JCB machines) over a six month period.

Once this started, it was natural for the UP government to step-in and put a stop to these atrocities. The government used a three-pronged strategy to defeat Nagpal and her supporters. This strategy can serve as a template for any state across the country which is struggling to reign in errant honest bureaucrats.

patronisingly Approach 1: Murder the Honest

Uttar Pradesh’s competency at knocking-off people who are attempting to do their jobs honestly, is unmatched across the world. Normally this would seem as an extreme measure, but not in UP. The expertise developed by the state has ensured that economies of scale have been achieved for this technique. Over the past few decades, Behenji Mayawati and Mulayam have been political foes but have beautifully complemented each other in creating an environment conducive for this method to thrive.

Nagpal was issued numerous death threats. She was also attacked by the sand mafia at Kasna police station. She was saved as her two security guards fired several rounds to chase away the armed goons.

Nagpal’s aide, Ashish Kumar, a district mining officer has to date survived three attempts on his life. During one of these attempts, a mob of more than 10 men armed with country-made pistols attacked his car. Ashish returned fire from his licenced private revolver.

Regrettably for the mafia, these tactics failed. Neither Nagpal nor Kumar were successfully dealt with through this method.

Approach 2: Transfer the Honest

It’s probably the most overused method of dealing with wayward honest public-servants, but one that is time-tested and reliable. Systematic methods have been developed by Uttar Pradesh to ensure that bureaucrats who show even a shred of character, are dealt with obscure transfers that inhibit their professional growth.

It was decided that Nagpal would be weakened by targeting key personnel around her. To get started, Ashish Kumar, was transferred to UP’s Bulandshahr a couple of days before the state government cracked down on Nagpal. Later on, Ravikant Singh, the Gautam-Budh Nagar District Magistrate who had been supportive of Nagpal, was removed from his post and put on a ‘wait-list’. And to really drive the point home, Nagpal’s husband, Abhishek Singh was transferred from the post of Executive Officer of Dadri Municipality in Ghaziabad district to Jhansi in the backward Bundelkhand. This area is considered relatively insignificant as compared to the postings in Ghaziabad district, and in Noida and Greater Noida (both in Gautam-Buddh Nagar district).

This approach helped the state government strategically weaken key supporters of Nagpal. But the killer blow to Nagpal came from the next approach.

Approach 3: Fabricate cases against the Honest

UP has mastered the technique of forming a nexus between politicians and criminals. In the words of Lambu Aata from the hit movie Gunda – गुंडागिरी और नेतागिरी दोनों एक ही बाप की दो हरामी औलाद है! (Crime and politics both are bastards from the same father).

The saint of the state. Upholder of the right to freedom of corruption.
The saint of UP. Upholder of the right to freedom of corruption.

The disgruntled SP heavyweight, Narendra Bhatti came up with a master-plan to put a stop to Nagpal for once and for all. In July, Nagpal was made aware of the construction of an illegal wall for a mosque in Kadalpur village, Greater Noida. Being a keener, and an unusually sincere public servant, Nagpal took it upon herself to have the wall demolished. Nagpal claims that this action was well within the rules of service and as per the directions of the Supreme Court. But do the UP administrative bigwigs care for the Supreme Court? Of course not! Nagpal was immediately suspended based on the whims of Narendra Bhatti who is an MP from Gautam-Budh Nagar. In fact Bhatti was so efficient, that he claimed later on that it took him all but 41 minutes to get Nagpal suspended! Incidentally, the same Bhatti has a criminal case pending against him in court including a charge for ‘attempted murder’.

UP’s crown prince, Akhilesh Yadav also chimed in with golden words. He said that, “If an official makes a mistake then the government punishes the official. This is the way government works.” Nagpal’s mistake was doing her job honestly. What a monster!

So this is how UP’s well-oiled criminal-politico machinery systematically removed one of the biggest thorns in its flesh. This story should serve as a reminder to any public-servant across the land who aspires to be honest and sincere. Think again. Else prepare for a life of gloom and misery.

———–

Sources
Digiprove sealCopyright secured by Digiprove

10 thoughts on “Best Approaches to stopping Honest Bureaucrats: A definitive guide from Uttar Pradesh

  1. In Bangalore urban district several temples are built on government lands in spite of the supreme court order ..the dc district collector sleeps over the order.

  2. Unfortunately,it is not state specific.
    It is one thing to criticises the politicians.It is also a fact that Babus are tempted towards juicy assignments,they bend rules for the polity.
    There are a few which live by standards but,land up in situations like Durga Shakti

  3. This is the actual Condition in India.The Politicians are use their Power for doing this kind of injustice.This is very unfortunate thing.Why our Politician do this kind of things. but now we are going to arrange the Debate on Corruption in India,where we invites all the Media and Politician to Participate in Debate.

  4. burecats of indian services are getting to with reastically and inspirationally to services and serve people but some situations and some incidents are making them to be sotware eng not as acivil burecats we the people and media are not recognising sinciere burecats and even our sociecty is not protecting them so civil and allburecats are working as se and selfish

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.